User blog comment:DarkShadow99/Regarding Rich/@comment-25947914-20161229103710/@comment-8117023-20170813141258


 * "Perhaps you mix up opinions and criticism with defamation."

No, I am not. Defamation is ' the action of damaging the good reputation of someone; slander or libel '. Criticism and opinions are centred around perceived or interpreted faults. Nightmare's statement about power abuse was quite clearly written as a statement of fact as he was previously presenting his permaban on Gatchaman Wiki as 'proof'.
 * "As I have said your post in that thread gave the impression that you thought that Nightmare would want to cause trouble. "

Once again, that is irrelevant. It was already clear from my use of verbs like 'if' and 'could' that I was not accusing him on meatpuppetry and your perception of my comments does not contradict this in the least.
 * "Also you might not have known him then, but you know now (even if you denied it without giving a valid reason and instead a full stop) that the thread on CC including your post has contributed to his suicide."

One more time...

None of my comments towards him were hostile or cutting - I tried to be as pragmatic as possible when responding. The only time that I was even remotely harsh or blunt was when I was asking him to remove the blog post you made (since we seem to be playing the blame game here). However, as soon as it was deleted, our discussion quickly turned more calm and collected and I even reassured him that the wiki wasn't going to die. This was in November 2015, mind you - 13 months before his death. If you honestly think that a cordial conversation, where our problems were practically resolved, was a key factor in his suicide, a reality check is in order. From what I have seen, he actually spent quite a lot of time apologising on your behalf when you kept on running your mouth and exacerbating the situation. In fact, wasn't one of your remarks one of Nbajammer's primary reasons for the blocks in 2015?
 * "Has someone a knife? I want to stab this overweight tyrant to death in person. Great that you blocked him Nightmare. Hopefully staff soon rids all of Wikia from this fat mafia bastard."

You can't claim to know the reasons why somebody committed suicide because you don't know. Only the person who died knew so projecting your own grudges onto Nightmare doesn't make your assumptions correct.
 * "Also just because Nightmare is too nice to place the blame on anyone doesn't mean I should also be this way."

You cannot blame me for something when Nightmare specifically stated that no one else was to blame. If he didn't say anyone else was to blame, your projections mean nothing.
 * "As I mentioned earlier in this post we think that you accuse Nightmare of stirring up trouble. Thus it could be as well that we misinterpreted your comments"

That would be the case, yes.